‘I look forward to the day when you are able to discuss something other than the election (though I fear you will suffer from severe Post-Partisan Depression).’ — the estimable Less Antman
Yesterday, I pointed you here for a very handy site on closed-end funds, promising to tell you today what they are and some of their pros and cons.
Maybe the best way to start is with a related question one of you asked: ‘How do you buy shares of closed-end funds selling at a discount? Why would they be selling at a discount? I thought that closed funds meant that you can’t get into them.’
Mmmmm . . . no. You’re confusing two very different things.
Some regular mutual funds do close their doors temporarily (or permanently) to new investors — but they are not what’s meant by closed-end funds. To redeem your shares, you still send them to the mutual fund company and get 100% of their then net asset value. And if you already own shares and want to buy some more, you mail a check to the mutual fund.
A closed-end fund, by contrast – also known as a ‘publicly traded fund’ — is sold to the public through brokers, just like a new stock. Typically, it will debut at $10 a share. (Never buy closed-end funds on the initial public offering, because once the underwriter takes his fee, you are in effect paying $10 for what may be only $9.50 in assets.) After the initial public offering — perhaps 20 million shares are sold at $10 each — the only way to buy the shares is in the open market from someone who already owns them and wants to sell. And the only way to sell them is on the open market to someone who wants to buy. (I.e., you can’t redeem them with the fund company.)
If a lot of people want to get in and not too many are keen on getting out, the price goes up — sometimes to a premium far above the value of the underlying assets of the fund. More often, they sell at a discount, especially in a bear market. (So there you have a double whammy: the underlying value of the fund has dropped with the bear market, and the discount has widened, to boot.)
Typically, they sell at a discount for several reasons.
One is that most money managers can’t beat the averages — so why pay 100 cents on the dollar for assets out of which is typically taken 1% a year in management fees? If GM is worth $50 a share, wouldn’t GM’s performance-minus-1%-a-year be worth only $45, if that? Well, a closed-end fund may own GM and 50 other stocks, and the same reasoning applies to the whole batch.
(The site I linked you to yesterday shows the expense ratios and discounts for virtually all closed-end funds.)
If you think this money manager can out perform the market by 1%, thus covering his fee and matching the market, then the fund should sell at 100 cents on the dollar. If you think she can not just beat the market by enough to pay her own fee but add an extra 1% or 2% or 5% of performance to boot — as few can — then you might reasonably pay a premium.
Another reason closed-ends typically sell for a discount is that people know they do, expect them to — and thus resist bidding them up to full value. Or look at it this way. They know closed-ends rarely sell at a premium but can drop to 90% or 80% or in a bad market perhaps even to 70% or 65% of net asset value. (Some, of course, will do better than others.) Knowing that, why risk paying 100 cents on the dollar? You expect a bit of a bargain to induce you to take this extra risk.
Theoretically, closed-end managers could end the discount and enrich their owners by going ‘open-end’ — i.e., offering to redeem whatever shares were tendered at net asset value. Suddenly, each $1 of assets would be redeemable for $1, so the fund would sell for about 100% of its value.
But that could mean less money under management and, in turn, less money for the fund manager. So instead they often do the opposite. Rather than offer to redeem your existing shares, they ‘force’ you to buy more. How? By offering you and all the other shareholders the ‘right’ to buy additional shares at 5% or more ‘off’ the going market price.
You’re not literally forced to buy, of course; but if you don’t, your own shares become a little diluted in value by the discount given those who do accept the offer.
(Closed-ends know many shareholders don’t like these rights offerings, but make them anyway to expand the pool of capital they have under management, from which they can take fees.)
In short, closed-ends can offer great value. Or not. Only buy them when they do.
Quote of the Day
I do count my blessings, but then I end up counting those of others who have more and better blessings, and that pisses me off.~Bob Mankoff New Yorker cartoon caption
Request email delivery
- Jan 19:
The Three Big Lies
- Jan 18:
Two Harvard Grads Still For Trump
- Jan 15:
Of Insurrection, Inequality, And Your Stocks
- Jan 14:
Meanwhile . . .
- Jan 13:
Ronald Reagan Speaks
- Jan 12:
What Do Adelson and Netanyahu Think?
- Jan 10:
Post Trump, Post Truth
- Jan 8:
Mark Twain Weighs In
- Jan 7:
Imagine . . .
- Jan 6:
Will On Pence
- Jan 19: