As much a I hope everyone reads Caste, so we have a common understanding of our shared history, I also hope we’ll keep from going off the deep end. Which is why those five minutes are must-watch, too.
Common sense frequently resides closer to the center than to either extreme.
Removing statues celebrating those who fought the United States Army to preserve slavery ?
But canceling Abraham Lincoln?
That’s where context and proportionality come in.
He held views he would not if he were alive today. (And who knows where he’d have been on net neutrality?) But should he not mainly be remembered for fighting to keep the country together and moving toward freedom?
Removing statues of Stalin makes sense to me. (The Soviets did that.) But am I crazy for thinking it’s okay no one’s torn down Tolstoy? (His family owned serfs.)
How about Ben Franklin? He owned slaves.
Context and “proportionality” really matter. Al Franken should still be in the Senate.
Some issues, it seems to me, are by now past discussion: Slavery is an abomination. Lynching is an abomination. The holocaust happened and was an abomination. Period. Case closed.
That we have some people who disagree — who wear Camp Auschwitz sweat shirts as they storm the Capitol carrying Trump banners and Confederate Flags — is appalling and frightening and deeply sad.
But tons of issues — like “reparations” (what to call them, whether we’ve already made them, how most fairly and effectively to make more if more remain to be made) — call for thoughtful discussion, with extreme views on either side welcome, but a modestly-left-of-center compromise usually the best path forward. (If you ask me; or a modestly right-of-center compromise if you ask some of my friends.)
People shouldn’t be “canceled” on either side for engaging in such discussions — or for having expressed views in 2010 or 1995 or high school — they may well not hold today.
Another issue past discussion, like slavery, one would hope, is the right to vote. Even Republican legislators know they must at least pretend to agree it should be easy for any adult citizen to vote and have that vote counted.
And yet, for your consideration:
If you’d like to fight back, click here. Early money is like yeast.
Have a great weekend. Summer’s in the air!
Quote of the Day
Everyman is guilty of all the good he didn't do.~Voltaire
Request email delivery
- Oct 19:
Barney, Chris, and Rudy
- Oct 18:
We Are In Good Hands
- Oct 14:
Pessimism: Meet Optimism
- Oct 13:
Plants Of The Gods
- Oct 10:
Why I’m Not Leaving America
- Oct 8:
A Letter From The Mayor Of Milford
- Oct 7:
He May Cure Your Diabetes AND Be A Great Mayor
- Oct 5:
- Oct 4:
The Conservative Case For $4 Trillion
- Oct 1:
- Oct 19: