Skip to content
Andrew Tobias
Andrew Tobias

Money and Other Subjects

  • Home
  • Books
  • Videos
  • Bio
  • Archives
  • Links
  • Me-Mail
Andrew Tobias
Andrew Tobias

Money and Other Subjects

Spiders vs. Diamonds

July 15, 1998February 5, 2017

From Derek Deer: “Why are spiders so much more popular than diamonds? (Today’s trading volume was at over a 10 to 1 ratio). Both have similar expense fees of .18%. The long term performance of both indexes (as well as the NASDAQ) are [sic] very similar. Does it have to do with distribution of dividends?”

A.T.: Two reasons, I would guess:

First, spiders (the nickname for a “stock” with the symbol SPY that basically gives you a tiny piece of all the stocks in the Standard & Poor’s 500 index) were invented first. The folks who wanted a way to trade the equivalent of an index fund took a liking to them, got used to them, and have no particular reason to switch.

Second, the S&P is a much broader, more sensibly calculated index than the Dow (which diamonds – symbol DIA – mimic). So for those who seek true market-weighting, spiders make more sense.

(The Dow is only 30 stocks compared with 500 for the S&P, so it’s less representative of “the market.” And it is calculated without regard to logic, which makes it less representative still. To make the point, imagine a day on which 28 of the 30 Dow stocks are unchanged, but two others move up and down $3 each. A $30 stock in the Dow rises $3, which is to say 10%, and a $100 stock in the Dow falls $3, which is to say just 3%. The 10% and 3% moves are considered equal – $3 is $3 – and the Dow, in this example, closes unchanged. It becomes all the less sensible if that $30 stock happened to have 2 billion shares outstanding, meaning that it had a $60 billion market capitalization that just gained $6 billion … and the $100 stock had just 100 million shares out, giving it a $10 billion market cap that just dropped $300 million. As far as the Dow Jones Industrial Average is concerned, it was a wash: the $300 million loss and $6 billion gain are considered equivalent. This is not to say the stupidity of the way the Dow is calculated doesn’t largely cancel itself out, or that Derek is wrong: The various indices do tend to move largely in tandem. Nor is it to knock Messrs. Dow and Jones, who would have been hard-pressed, sans pocket calculators let alone computers, to calculate it differently. But still.)

 

Post navigation

← Report from Russia
MITTS Friends Like These … →

Quote of the Day

"Borrow money from pessimists -- they don't expect it back."

Steven Wright

Subscribe

 Advice

The Only Investment Guide You'll Ever Need

"So full of tips and angles that only a booby or a billionaire could not benefit." -- The New York Times

Help

MYM Emergency?

Too Much Junk?

Tax Questions?

Ask Less

Recent Posts

  • How To Fix Our Failing Public Schools

    November 12, 2026
  • Jon Stewart Loves "60 Minutes"

    November 10, 2026
  • Defiance!

    November 10, 2026
  • A Letter to the President

    November 9, 2026
  • Diverse Voters, Scary Stocks, Bully Pulpits

    November 8, 2026
  • Tuxedos And More

    November 6, 2026
  • A Few More Thoughts

    November 5, 2026
  • Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy -- Part 2

    November 4, 2026
  • Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy, Oh, Boy

    November 3, 2026
  • For Him, It's Like Breathing

    November 1, 2026
Andrew Tobias Books
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
©2026 Andrew Tobias - All Rights Reserved | Website: Whirled Pixels | Author Photo: Tony Adams