Skip to content
Andrew Tobias
Andrew Tobias

Money and Other Subjects

  • Home
  • Books
  • Videos
  • Bio
  • Archives
  • Links
  • Me-Mail
Andrew Tobias
Andrew Tobias

Money and Other Subjects

Using Uncle Sam’s Money

September 30, 2002February 21, 2017

Jeff Percival: ‘I saw your Parade piece last week, where you pointed out that someone in a tax-deferred plan is taxed on withdrawal as income, but someone not in a plan pays a lower (we hope) capital gains rate. This sounds great, but in thinking about it, I’m not so sure. I always thought that the key idea behind tax-deferred plans is that you hope to be taxed when you are retired, at a lower income bracket. Without this condition, I always thought it was a wash: after all, whether you tax your initial investment then double it, or instead double it first and then tax it, you end up with exactly the same amount of money. You only win if the tax rate at the end is lower than at the beginning.’

☞ Are you sure? For the sake of argument/simple math, say you’re in the 50% bracket now and will be at withdrawal. One way, you put in $1,000 now (pre-tax) and earn 10% a year (pre-tax) for 40 years. That $1,000 grows to $45,260 – and then half is taxed away, leaving you $22,630. The other way, outside a retirement plan, you put in $500 (what’s left of the same $1,000 of income after tax) and it grows for 40 years at 5% (not 10% because of tax) to $3,520. So it’s not a wash at all. In this example, you wind up, after tax, with more than six times as much. Why? Because for all those years you had the ‘government’s’ share of your money working for you as well as your own.

Using more realistic tax brackets and noting the likelihood of long-term gains treatment on appreciation outside the retirement plan, the gap narrows. But for most people, there’s definitely an advantage in tax-deferred growth, especially over long periods of time.


Did you read Paul Krugman’s column in the New York Times Friday? Click here. That California energy crisis may not have been so innocent, after all.

Post navigation

← Less Casual Saturday
Harvard’s President on Anti-Semitism →

Quote of the Day

"There is nothing like higher prices to attract more buyers. In department stores you mark merchandise down to move it. On Wall Street you mark it up."

Michael Metz, Oppenheimer

Subscribe

 Advice

The Only Investment Guide You'll Ever Need

"So full of tips and angles that only a booby or a billionaire could not benefit." -- The New York Times

Help

MYM Emergency?

Too Much Junk?

Tax Questions?

Ask Less

Recent Posts

  • Standing With Dictators Against Freedom

    November 20, 2026
  • Then Everything Changed

    November 18, 2026
  • The Money Agenda

    November 18, 2026
  • Sam, Thom, and Rob

    November 16, 2026
  • New York!

    November 15, 2026
  • I Love It

    November 12, 2026
  • How To Fix Our Failing Public Schools

    November 12, 2026
  • Jon Stewart Loves "60 Minutes"

    November 10, 2026
  • Defiance!

    November 10, 2026
  • A Letter to the President

    November 9, 2026
Andrew Tobias Books
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
©2026 Andrew Tobias - All Rights Reserved | Website: Whirled Pixels | Author Photo: Tony Adams